Charlie, a morbidly obese professor, tries to reconnect with his estranged daughter, Ellie. In the end, he stands up and walks towards her, enveloped in bright light, symbolizing redemption and emotional closure.
Charlie’s Struggle and Redemption
Charlie, played by Brendan Fraser, weighs over 600 pounds and lives in isolation. His partner, Alan, has died, leaving Charlie in deep grief. He teaches online writing classes from his apartment, hiding his appearance from his students. His main goal is to mend his relationship with his daughter, Ellie, who resents him for abandoning her and her mother.
Charlie’s interactions with his friend Liz and a missionary named Thomas reveal his internal battles. Liz, a nurse, cares for him but is frustrated by his refusal to seek medical help. Thomas, on the other hand, tries to save Charlie’s soul, believing his obesity is a sin. These characters highlight the external pressures Charlie faces while he struggles with his own guilt and desire for redemption.
Ellie, played by Sadie Sink, is initially hostile towards Charlie. She feels abandoned and betrayed. However, as the film progresses, she begins to see her father’s genuine remorse and desire to reconnect. This elaborate relationship forms the emotional core of the film.
The Climactic Ending
In the final moments, Charlie, on the brink of death, makes a significant effort to stand up and walk towards Ellie. This act is symbolic of his emotional journey towards redemption. As he stands, the film transitions into a surreal sequence where he is enveloped in bright light. This suggests a transcendence or ascension, contrasting sharply with the dark, claustrophobic atmosphere of his apartment.
The last image shows a younger, slimmer Charlie on a beach, watching Ellie play in the sand. This flashback serves as a poignant reminder of happier times and symbolizes the hope and connection he yearns for throughout the film. The ending is visually striking and emotionally resonant, leaving a lasting impact on the audience (1).
Multiple Interpretations
The ending of The Whale invites various interpretations. Some viewers see Charlie’s final moments as a deathbed hallucination. They question whether he truly achieves the connection he seeks with Ellie or if it is merely a figment of his imagination as he slips away. This ambiguity allows for rich discussions about redemption and the human experience of love and loss (2).
Brendan Fraser himself suggests that Charlie’s final act of walking towards Ellie represents a moment of liberation rather than a literal death. This interpretation aligns with the film’s theme of seeking forgiveness and connection. It suggests that Charlie’s journey is not solely about his physical demise but also about achieving emotional closure (3).
Thematic Resonance
The ending encapsulates the film’s exploration of redemption and the human desire for connection. Charlie’s struggle with his weight and past mistakes serves as a metaphor for the burdens we carry and the lengths we go to seek forgiveness. The bright light and beach scene evoke a sense of hope, contrasting with the despair that permeates much of the film. This duality reflects the elaborateity of human emotions, where moments of joy can coexist with profound sadness (4).
Aronofsky’s adaptation introduces a more hopeful note compared to the original play’s somber conclusion. This suggests that even in the face of tragedy, there can be moments of beauty and connection. The film’s ending diverges from the play, offering a sense of hope and redemption that resonates deeply with audiences.
Critical Reception
The Whale has received mixed reviews. Critics praise Fraser’s performance but raise concerns about the film’s portrayal of obesity. The film holds a 64% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, indicating mixed reviews, yet it boasts a 91% audience score. This highlights a significant divide between critical and public perception. The ending, in particular, has been a focal point for discussions, with some viewing it as a cathartic release while others criticize it for being overly sentimental or manipulative (5).
Conclusion
The ending of The Whale serves as a powerful culmination of Charlie’s journey. It encapsulates themes of redemption, connection, and the elaborateity of human emotions. The ambiguity surrounding Charlie’s final moments invites viewers to reflect on their interpretations, making it a subject of ongoing discussion and analysis. As audiences grapple with the film’s emotional weight, The Whale stands as a testament to the enduring human desire for forgiveness and the hope for connection, even in the face of overwhelming adversity.
References
